top of page

The HR Problem

Writer: Ade McCormack
Ade McCormack
Nov 5
5 min read
How can HR justify its people budget?

The problem

How can HR make a compelling case for investment when those controlling the budget cannot tell whether a dollar spent on people creates two dollars of business value—or less than one? Will a bar chart showing favourable feedback scores from the latest induction programme or leadership awayday settle the matter?


A happy, fulfilled workforce is gratifying, but this alone does not demonstrate a direct contribution to business performance.


The quantifiable value of people is a reasonable question, but only if the organisation operates as a machine and people as cogs. A better factory will emerge if each machine component is task optimised. Such reductionism worked well during the industrial era, a period when apart from the occasional disruption, predictability was the norm.


So a quantified answer only applies if we continue to see people as factory-machine components, ie recruited solely to follow the operations manual without deviation. In this respect, particularly with the emergence of AI, people are no more than technology placeholders. Consequently there will be leaders who believe that swapping out people with technology will result in a more frictionless and more profitable machine.


The real problem

Applying industrial-era principles to a post-industrial, increasingly disruptive world is the fundamental problem. Leaders pickled in industrial thinking treat scientific management as the only credible way to organise work and assess performance.


Perhaps the messiness of managing ‘living cogs’ explains why responsibility for people was delegated to a specialist department, variously labelled personnel, HR, talent or people. Much like IT, it became a function whose necessity the leadership accepted, even if it struggled to articulate the value it created.


So in many cases, the Chief HR Officer, where they exist, continues to be a victim of the business strategy rather than a co-creator. Thus the HR function acquires all the responsibility without the associated autonomy.


Trust no-one

In keeping with Taylorism, much of HR embraced a reductionist view of work, drifting towards administering people and the associated processes, which broadly have little to do with treating people as humans. Rigid job specifications and a preoccupation with compliance reinforced the idea of people as interchangeable cogs.


The organisation became a galley ship. When more output was needed, management quickened the drumbeat. When profitability faltered, fewer rowers were expected to pull harder. In recent years, the demands for speed and effort have intensified. People are paying the price as their energy becomes the last reserve executives draw upon to keep an outdated business model looking profitable.


A major consequence of Covid-19 was the outbreak of worker surveillance. Surveillance technology flourished, promising ever finer scrutiny of employees’ activity. Where this has become the basis of management, the ambition to build a performance culture through shared purpose and a common esprit de corps has given way to institutionalised suspicion.


Every employee is now a potential ‘enemy within’. With such a tension, it is hardly surprising that AI’s appeal centres on its potential to eliminate workers. The sun finally sets on HR’s promise of being the people’s champion. People police might be more accurate.


So here we are.


Mind blown

Both HR and the leadership team need to develop a more nuanced understanding of how the world has changed and the real value that people can bring to the table.


The world is no longer ordered, and neither are most organisations. The former is chaotic and the latter is complex. So treating your top shelf management consulting firm like a well-furnished factory, where the conveyor belt is replaced by an intranet, needs a radical rethink. Mechanical objects whether they be factories, cuckoo clocks or sausage machines are optimised for order and not chaos. As readers of my work will know, I believe the way forward is more biological than mechanical.


HR policing attempts to impose mechanical order on an inherently complex human system is failing. People are not cogs. They are curious, social beings with a need for autonomy, connection and self-expression. No amount of upbeat internal communication will inspire them to ‘seize the day’ if their everyday work experience is one of surveillance, suspicion and control. Does your workplace reflect a high-performance gymnasium or an off-book CIA psyops experiment?


The funk, soul worker

I have written extensively about the systemic and structural changes that industrial era-birthed organisations need to make. So let us assume that your organisation is now operating intelligently, and your people feel the workplace offers the perfect conditions to achieve self-mastery. A rough proxy, imagine your organisation is a nightclub:


  • Is the dancefloor packed with people, self-expressing, who have no intention of leaving?

  • Is there a long queue of people outside who are eager to partake?


Still, there remains the issue of demonstrating the value of investing in people. The leadership now buys the idea that people are critical to the organisation, and perhaps even believe that they are the organisation’s ‘most valuable asset’. But they still do not know if they are over or underspending in respect of the workforce.


The next big shift is to develop a performance, rather than an activity culture. Industrial organisations paid workers for their time. Over time, the workers became skilled at doing the least work needed to remain employed. Such lazy workers thus needed policing. This practice is better known today as management.


Performative behaviour

Once an organisation focuses on outcomes, it becomes easier to investigate how investment in people contributes to organisational value. Consider the shift in emphasis:


Investment

Activity or reaction measure

Evidence of improved performance

Leadership development

Attendance and course ratings

Better decisions, assessed against clear objectives and subsequent outcomes

Employee wellbeing

Programme participation

Reduced avoidable absence and unwanted employee turnover

AI training

Training completions and tool adoption

Higher-quality work, faster delivery and useful ideas developed and tested

Cross-functional development

Number of participants

Faster problem resolution, fewer handoff failures and improved customer satisfaction

 

These measures do not, by themselves, establish a precise dollar-in, dollar-out return. They do provide evidence for further investigation. We still need to ask what changed, over what period and what else might explain the result.


In a complex organisation the impact of an investment will be driven by such factors as leadership, culture, technology and market conditions. Carefully designed comparisons can help establish causality, but attributing the full impact to one intervention is rarely straightforward.


Is she worth it?

Consider a struggling football team signing an exceptional player. Their contribution may extend well beyond goals and assists. Their presence might unsettle opponents, raise teammates’ confidence, attract larger crowds and make the club more appealing to emerging talent. Equally, poor tactics or fractured relationships could prevent that potential from translating into results. The return partly depends on the system the player joins, and how their arrival changes it. Complex, indeed.


The same applies to investment in people. An employer reputation that attracts scarce talent, strengthens customer confidence and earns investor interest may be evidence of a valuable organisational capability. HR and the executive team might well investigate how that capability creates value and what sustains it.


Difficulty assigning an exact financial return is no reason to assume it has none. Human performance management is not an exact science.

The ideas continue to evolve

Follow my thinking and receive each new perspective as it's published. Together they explore how organisations can remain viable, vital and valuable in an increasingly unknowable world.

Navigation

The ideas on this website are organised as a journey:

​

  1. The challenges leaders face

  2. The traditional organisational lenses used to address the challenges

  3. The principles that empower organisations to navigate an increasingly disrupted world

  4. The outcomes that ensure your organisation survives, thrives and matters.

bottom of page